Making a top-list of anything is quite hard as so many factors come into play. How many had the game? Was it a cheap budget cassette game that sold 1000th or a expensive disc only in limited editions? Or should it be judged by technical excellence or just for having simplistic fun gameplay or having a challenging mindboggling hard gameplay? When was the game sold (within the amstrad "lifetime" or) and does later games or remakes count as well.
Just looking at the list and i see 12 games i didnt have back then. This dosnt mean much tho as i saw most of the games back then while playing games at friends etc. But still there is a couple that makes me go "huh?".
Like Sorcery+ .. how many people actually had that game? Wasnt this a disc only game and who actually had a disc drive in 1985? The people who could actually play this back then must have been so few that they couldnt form a soccer team if they wanted. Or perhaps im missing something being non-uk? Still, im surpriced that this old game jumping in as the 6th best amstrad game ever, lol.
First impression i from looking at the list was: some spectrum owners going "did you see that game? Those amstrad owners musta loved that one"-vibe. Or perhaps a bit of youtube 8bit wars comparison .. like there is game in there simply because someone rated them better than another systems version of the same game.
Then there is A.T.F .. my mind had to look it over a few times until i noticed that it was not a typo of A.M.C, lol.
Personally id probably remove Batman as it is a really ok game but Head Over Heels is already in there (Batman would probably fit nicely in a top 100, and i dare not say freely my opinion of the 4 colour mode 1 3D iso games either).
Exolon is also a great game and even tho all games by Raffaele Cecco are great .. its one of the earliest games so it could swap place with one of the later more impressive ones.
I do feel Arkanoid is missing in there somehow. Apart from the first one and the Doh one there was made at least another 3 or 4 verisons more by people who like the games so much that they hacked the originals and released their own underground versions. Also seen from a "popularity" view id think a lot would have voted for Ghost N Goblins and Lightforce.
Oh well, what do i know .. im still the silly fella who felt that Green Beret was a really cool game and it wasnt untill about 15 years later i got online and learned how wrong i was